Don't need this anymore. I ended up using two sets of anti fatigue mats from harbor freight ($6.99 ea before coupons), which enabled me to trip each 1/2" level so it fit the topography of the bottom and sides. I also ended cutting my old foam insert to hold the jack, and moved that to the passenger side of the spare. I bought a foam spare insert for a G37 on eBay for $35, and it is good to go. Not perfect, but for less than $50 total, I don't think you can beat it.
Ideally you would want the mat for the back the fits the spare as the non spare mat has a 4" lip on the inside edge. I spaced/supported that out with the foam edge pieces and can still access my pass through.
I ended up cutting the spare insert to fit my manual so I opened up some glove box space as well.
All told, I lost about 4" of depth, but for piece of mind to have a good spare and no RFTs anymore, it was worth it.
See the pics below for details.